Dispensable/Indispensable Attributes

Indispensable and dispensable attributes are akin to mediums that are, and are not, morphophoric.

Figure 4: Two projected dots.
\scalebox{.3}{\includegraphics{eps/dots.eps}}


Consider the following VISION example illustrating attributes of color and spatial position:

  1. two spots are projected side by side, one yellow and the other red;
  2. next, two spots are in same location but both orange (though dispensed with color, spatial position is preserved);
  3. next original red and yellow spots are projected on top of each other--only a single orange spot is visible;

Spatial position is thus indispensable: by dispensing with position, original yellow and red dots are not distinguishable.


``Music 175: Pitch II'' by Tamara Smyth, Department of Music, University of California, San Diego (UCSD).
Download PDF version (pitch2.pdf)
Download compressed PostScript version (pitch2.ps.gz)
Download PDF `4 up' version (pitch2_4up.pdf)
Download compressed PostScript `4 up' version (pitch2_4up.ps.gz)

Copyright © 2019-06-04 by Tamara Smyth.
Please email errata, comments, and suggestions to Tamara Smyth<trsmyth@ucsd.edu>